I've been thinking about how to play beater with
finesse ever since someone said something to me about beaters last week.
The thing is, a lot of beaters just hit those bludgers at the other team, and hit them away from their own team. Crash. Bang. All force. All reaction. You even see it in the pros. But clearly that's not all there is to it, and you can also see a few players who don't do it that way at all.
Oh, you need some of that crash bang, but you don't have to get it with mass. You can get it with speed too. And if you're fast, you can get there first, before those typical massive but not so maneuverable beaters.
Plus there's the interesting fact that bludgers go after people. And beaters are people.
So here's what I think:
1) If you can control the bludgers, you control the shape of the game based on where you might hit them. That is, no matter how much you trust your beaters, no one but a fool is going to deliberately fly into a position where a bludger is going to be. It's basically the same as having your rook on a file in chess -- if you control that file, in
general no one is going to move their queen there. It's just a metaphor, no need to tell me about deliberate sacrifices.
2) Bludgers are wild, they're the jokers of Quidditch. They're not meant to be controllable.
3) However, they don't teleport, and everything they do is continuous, so you can predict them to some degree. Plus, as I said before, they go after people, and they don't stray too far from the pitch. More predictability.
4) The faster you are, the more likely you can get to where the bludger is going to be before your opponent.
5) The closer you can match the bludger's trajectory, the less danger you're in from the bludger yourself.
6) I wanted to work in a reference to Patrick O'Brien and Napoleonic naval warfare -- the importance of having the weather gage! -- but I don't have time to get it to work. But all the same, I haven't forgotten the importance of having the weather gage, the amount of leeway you make, and the dangers of a lee shore as well!
It's not exactly a strategy, but it's very suggestive.
So that's why I'm trying out for beater too, tonight. Plus we need two of them, and I really want to make the team this year.